Tax Litigation

Tax Court of Canada Lawyer: Appeals Against CRA Reassessments

When the CRA will not change its position, the Tax Court of Canada is where independent judges decide whether the reassessment is correct. We represent individuals, families and businesses in Tax Court appeals, from filing the Notice of Appeal to settlement or trial.

90 days to appeal

A Notice of Appeal must generally be filed within 90 days after the CRA sends its notice confirming or varying the reassessment. If the CRA has not decided your objection within 90 days of filing, you can appeal without waiting.

What the Tax Court Decides

The Tax Court of Canada is a federal court with exclusive jurisdiction over appeals of assessments under the Income Tax Act, the Excise Tax Act (GST/HST), the Canada Pension Plan and Employment Insurance Act (including insurability and pensionable employment) and several other federal statutes. Judges are independent of the CRA, and the CRA is represented in court by lawyers from the Department of Justice.

The court decides whether the assessment is correct in law and fact. It can allow the appeal and vacate or vary the assessment, refer it back to the CRA for reconsideration, or dismiss it. Decisions can be appealed to the Federal Court of Appeal, and from there, with leave, to the Supreme Court of Canada.

Informal or General Procedure

The informal procedure is designed to be faster and less formal. It is generally available where the federal tax and penalties in dispute are $25,000 or less for each taxation year, or the loss in issue is $50,000 or less, and taxpayers can elect to limit their appeal to those amounts. Legislation passed in 2026 allows higher limits to be set, so we confirm the threshold in effect when filing. Informal procedure decisions are not binding precedents, and costs awards are limited.

The general procedure applies to larger disputes. It involves pleadings, exchange of documents, examinations for discovery, pre-trial procedures and strict rules of evidence. Costs can be awarded against the losing party, which affects settlement strategy. Corporations in the general procedure generally must be represented by a lawyer.

The Burden of Proof

In a tax appeal, the facts the CRA assumed when reassessing are generally presumed true, and the taxpayer must demolish them by making a case on the evidence. Once the taxpayer has done so, the burden shifts to the Crown. For gross negligence penalties and for reassessing statute-barred years, the burden is on the Crown from the start.

This makes evidence and preparation decisive. Testimony that is credible, consistent with documents and well organized wins cases. We prepare clients and witnesses thoroughly and use documentary evidence strategically.

  • Unreported income and net worth reassessments
  • Business expenses, shareholder benefits and loans
  • Real estate flipping, principal residence and HST disputes
  • GST/HST input tax credits and new housing rebates
  • Gross negligence penalties
  • Disability Tax Credit and benefit eligibility
  • Employee vs independent contractor (CPP/EI) appeals

Settlement Before Trial

Many Tax Court appeals settle before trial, often after documents have been exchanged and both sides have assessed the evidence. Settlements must be based on a principled view of the facts and law; the Crown generally cannot simply split the difference. A well-prepared case is the best route to a good settlement, and we evaluate offers candidly against the likely trial outcome.

Preparing for Your Day in Court

Tax Court hearings are public, and the judge decides the case based on the evidence presented at the hearing. Documents must be properly introduced, witnesses must be available, and testimony must be consistent with the records. Taxpayers who have not prepared often struggle under cross-examination by experienced Department of Justice lawyers, even when their position is sound.

We prepare a hearing plan for every case: the legal issues, the facts that must be proven, the witnesses who can prove them, and the documents that corroborate their testimony. We meet with you and your witnesses to review the evidence and explain what to expect, and we prepare written or oral argument referring the judge to the relevant legislation and case law. Good preparation also strengthens settlement discussions, since the Crown assesses the risk of trial based on the strength of the evidence.

How We Handle Your Matter

  1. 1

    Case assessment

    We review the objection file, the CRA's assumptions and the evidence to assess strengths and risks.

  2. 2

    Notice of Appeal

    We draft and file the Notice of Appeal within the deadline and choose the appropriate procedure.

  3. 3

    Pre-trial

    We exchange documents, conduct examinations for discovery and attend settlement conferences where applicable.

  4. 4

    Settlement or trial preparation

    We negotiate with the Department of Justice and prepare you and your witnesses for trial.

  5. 5

    Trial and beyond

    We present your case in court and advise on any further appeal.

Frequently Asked Questions

How long does a Tax Court appeal take?

Informal procedure appeals are generally heard more quickly, often within a year or so of filing. General procedure appeals often take two years or more, depending on complexity and settlement discussions.

Do I need a lawyer for the Tax Court?

Individuals may represent themselves, but tax appeals involve rules of evidence, legal tests and cross-examination by Department of Justice lawyers. Corporations in the general procedure generally must be represented by a lawyer.

Can I appeal without filing a Notice of Objection?

Generally no. You must file a Notice of Objection first, then appeal after the CRA decides, or after 90 days without a decision.

Will I have to pay the CRA's legal costs if I lose?

In the informal procedure, costs against the taxpayer are rare. In the general procedure, the court may award costs to the successful party, which is an important factor in strategy and settlement.

What is the filing fee for a Tax Court appeal?

There is no filing fee for an informal procedure appeal. General procedure appeals have a filing fee set by the Tax Court rules. We confirm current fees when preparing your appeal.

Is a Tax Court decision final?

Decisions can be appealed to the Federal Court of Appeal, generally within 30 days. Informal procedure decisions can only be reviewed on limited grounds. Further appeals to the Supreme Court of Canada require leave.

Speak With a Tax Lawyer Before You Respond to the CRA

Tax deadlines are strict and what you say to the CRA can be used in an assessment. A confidential consultation helps you understand your options before you act.

This page provides general information about Canadian tax law as of October 2026. It is not legal advice, and reading it does not create a lawyer-client relationship. Tax rules change and every situation is different, so please speak with a lawyer about your circumstances.

Call NowBook Consultation